Why Attention Alone Isn’t Enough

In a culture fueled by short-form videos and viral moments, grabbing attention has become an obsession. But as Gayle Rogers, founder of Atomic, reminds us, attention alone doesn’t translate to impact. “If you never have anybody’s attention, does anything you say really matter? But if all you’re trying to do is mine for attention and you’ll do anything to get it, will anybody really take you seriously?” he asks.

For today’s decision-makers, that question cuts deep. Marketing departments often measure success by impressions and engagement metrics, yet these surface-level wins rarely tell the full story. Rogers emphasizes that brands need more than visibility — they need credibility. Attention should be the door, not the destination.

The Trap of Vanity Metrics

Rogers warns against confusing popularity with performance. “I can see the likes and the shares and the comments,” he says, “but I can’t tell you whether or not it’s changing their business.” Vanity metrics make it easy to believe a campaign is working, but they often mask the lack of real ROI.

For leaders managing budgets and outcomes, the takeaway is clear: don’t mistake audience reaction for brand traction. Success should be measured in retention, trust, and the quality of engagement — not just the quantity.

Educate to Retain, Not Just Entertain

Entertainment gets people in the door, but education keeps them coming back. “Once you get them there, can you get them to stick around?” Rogers says. He argues that audiences seek content that gives them something useful: insights they can apply, perspectives that challenge them, or expertise that helps them make better decisions.

For decision-makers, this means shifting from a “look at me” approach to a “learn from me” one. The brands that win long-term are those that enrich their audience’s understanding, not just their screens.

Align Entertainment with Expertise

Rogers doesn’t dismiss the importance of entertainment. “Yes, I think you should be trying to find a way to engage and put a smile on people’s face,” He says. “But I also think it’s vitally important that you provide them value.” The best content does both: it captures attention and earns respect.

That balance turns casual viewers into committed customers, the ultimate metric for sustainable growth.

Building a Brand That Lasts

In both digital and brick-and-mortar contexts, Rogers’ advice rings true: “Keep the entertainment, grab people’s attention, but you’ve got to provide value.” Decision-makers who prioritize value-driven storytelling will build not only visibility but also trust — the foundation for long-term success.

At its core, sustainable marketing is about aligning entertainment with expertise. When those two forces work together, brands move beyond the noise and into lasting relevance.

---

1. What does it mean to balance entertainment and value in marketing?

Short Answer :
It means creating content that captures attention while also providing meaningful information or insight. Entertainment draws audiences in; value keeps them engaged and builds trust.

Detailed Answer :
Balancing entertainment and value means crafting content that’s both engaging and useful. Gayle Rogers of Atomic explains that while entertainment attracts people, it’s value that keeps them coming back. Brands should use entertainment as the hook — humor, storytelling, or surprise — and pair it with substance that informs or inspires. When content connects emotionally and intellectually, it builds credibility and loyalty. Rogers often reminds marketers, “Keep the entertainment, grab attention, but you’ve got to provide value.” That blend is what turns one-time viewers into long-term advocates.

---

2. Why are vanity metrics a problem for business decision-makers?

Short Answer :
Because they create a false sense of success. High engagement might look good, but if it doesn’t drive conversions, retention, or reputation, it’s not true ROI.

Detailed Answer :
Vanity metrics — likes, views, and shares — can make a campaign appear effective when it’s not. Rogers points out that these numbers “look good but don’t always mean growth.” They measure visibility, not impact. For decision-makers, this is dangerous because it diverts focus from real outcomes like qualified leads, retention rates, and brand credibility. The smarter approach is to track how content influences action: sign-ups, referrals, or repeat engagement. True ROI comes from meaningful interaction, not empty applause.

---

3. How can a brand measure real value from its content?

Short Answer :
Look at indicators of trust and loyalty — returning visitors, conversions, referrals, and content-driven sales. These reflect genuine business growth.

Detailed Answer :
To measure true content value, brands must look beyond impressions. Rogers advises focusing on metrics that reveal relationship strength: customer retention, time on page, brand mentions, and repeat interactions. Content that builds trust leads to tangible business results — like higher-quality leads and improved conversion rates. Track not only what draws attention, but what deepens engagement. When your audience takes consistent, value-based actions, that’s the clearest sign your content is working.

---

4. What happens if a brand focuses only on entertainment?

Short Answer :
It risks becoming irrelevant or inauthentic. Without substance, the audience loses interest quickly, and the brand’s credibility suffers.

Detailed Answer :
Entertainment-only strategies might generate buzz but rarely sustain business growth. Rogers warns that if you’re “just trying to get people to look at you,” your message will lose weight. Audiences crave substance — insights, takeaways, or solutions they can use. When content prioritizes spectacle over service, credibility erodes. A brand that entertains and educates builds respect and recall. The key is depth: make sure every laugh, trend, or visual moment serves a larger story.

---

5. How can leaders encourage teams to produce value-based content?

Short Answer :
Set clear goals tied to education, expertise, and brand integrity. Reward quality engagement and measurable impact, not just viral reach.

Detailed Answer :
Leadership sets the tone for meaningful marketing. Rogers recommends empowering teams with clarity — define success in terms of outcomes, not optics. Encourage creators to educate, not just entertain, and celebrate metrics like conversion, trust, or retention over likes and shares. Leaders should also model curiosity by asking: Does this content serve our audience’s needs? When teams know the “why” behind their work, they naturally align creativity with purpose — and that’s where real ROI begins.